About Us

Integrity Insurance has been in business since 1983. We are an independent agency, which means our agency represents several different companies. This makes it possible for us to offer products that are tailored to meet your needs.

integrity staff banner

In January 1983 this business was started in the North Lima area. The business was run out of a farmhouse until 1996 when I began my career as an insurance agent.  In May 1999, I purchased the Agency from the original owner and we are still providing that same care for our customers.  We believe with God as our foundation and people before profits, this business has become what it is today.


My wife Melissa and I have two beautiful grown daughters.  We spend our time traveling to new places and just enjoy being together.  I really enjoy helping people make decisions about their current and future insurance needs.  We value your trust and appreciate your business.

Brian Carter – President, Owner, Insurance Agent


My husband Brian and I really enjoy being part of a closely knit team here at Integrity Insurance.  I have been an agent since 2001 and assist in Marketing, Electronic Filing and scheduling annual reviews.  I love to read, spend time outdoors and travel with my husband.   I find joy in serving others.

-Melissa Carter – V-President, Owner, Insurance Agent


I joined Integrity Insurance in April of 2002. My husband, Steve and I have two wonderful grown children, a great daughter in law and two grandchildren. I like to travel, read and spend time with my family and friends. I am licensed in property and casualty and am ready to help you find the right policy for your insurance needs.

-Corina Wellman – Treasurer, Insurance Agent


tracyI have lived in this community my entire life and I have had the privilege of being a part of Integrity Insurance since 2000 (with a slight break). My husband, Joe, and I have 4 wonderful and very active children still at home. We enjoy spending time together, rushing off to activities and events, and getting together with friends. I am licensed in Property & Casualty and look forward to serving your ever-changing insurance needs.

-Tracey Bartholow – Insurance Agent